A Rebuttal to Partha Chatterjee’s article on the Indian Army

Written by
A Rebuttal to Partha Chatterjee's article on the Indian Army
Share the joy
  • 89
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

This article is in response to the article by Partha Chatterjee titled “In Kashmir India is witnessing its General Dyer Moment”.

Let us compare some lines from the article and see where truth fits in. Partha starts by comparing the British with Indian Government, Any sane person with reasonable IQ knows that General Dyer was not an Indian citizen and The british were not locally elected by Indian people and The queen was not an Indian Citizen and so they were occupational forces, But General Bipin is an Indian Citizen and Major Gogoi is an Indian citizen and The Indian government is not occupying Kashmir because Kashmir is an integral part of India, So he is questioning India’s Sovereignty, the very title of the article clearly shows Partha’s bias and his anti nationalism,Because he is subtly questioning Kashmir being part of India. So the title of the article shows his seed of Hatred towards Indian Republic,No wonder the rest of his article only branches from the seed of Hatred towards India.

Let us go to the Next Comparison which shall prove beyond doubt that the author is lacking basic common sense….Dyer a foreign citizen enters a foreign country on behalf of a Foreign occupational country and shoots and kills Innocent native Patriotic Indians without mercy which could have been avoided because he was very well informed about the preceding agitation and the context,He was not short of time nor resources or information,But he still butchers the PATRIOTIC NATIVES…How can you compare the above with our situation where Gogoi an Indian citizen is in Kashmir an indivisible part of India representing the Native Country and is faced with Separatists and Anti Nationals and has to rescue Indian citizen voters,armed service personnel and Government workers from physical violence,he has no Time to think or Waste because everything happens suddenly, Above all this, he has strict instructions not to shoot any Anti nationals too!!!! Being smart and Ingenious the officer takes a decision that prevented his personnel from shooting the miscreants,Thus avoiding a massive Bloodshed…Now how can we compare this with Dyer shooting Patriotic Indians by arms and Gogoi using a strategy which helped him from not firing a single bullet on Non patriotic Indians..One example creates lot of bloodshed where the other does not even make a single person bleed….Is this a JUST comparison??? The IQ level of Partha is clearly cognizable here.

Partha argues here that Jallianwalabagh Massacre lead to a mass outcry,Well the proof is in the pudding, Jallianwalabagh united all Patriotic Indians and became the Stepping stone of success for the end of British Empire in India,After Gogoi incident too we can see whole Patriotic Indians getting united,Maybe this will be the Stepping stone of Success against Anti Nationals including the people like Partha and his Pseudo intellectual Ilk. The author’s double standard is clearly noticeable when time and again he cries saying how can the army try this on its own people but again he question’s “was action necessary?”, because only 7 percent voters showed up..Does the author mean that this percentage of population is not inportant to be protected???? Major Gogoi actually did nothing new,In fact he emulated our great forefathers like Krishna and Mahatma Gandhi…Krishna did not even lift his arms in the Kurukshetra war,but he made sure Adharma was defeated,Gandhi also did not resort to arms but was useful in sending the British back,Now Gogoi did the same, Nothing new…except in this case our own disguised media is trying to paint our heroes as villains. For his great presence of mind Mr. Gogoi should be rewarded but instead the media is trying to hang him, American special forces teams, time and again conduct Critical operations for their country and their media supports them and they do not release their names, some names are released after long time,But these days Its easy for anti nationals to get media permit and infiltrate in our ranks and in the name of press freedom, they are releasing critical information which is detrimental to our country’s unity and integrity,Who is responsible if Mr. Gogoi or his family are harmed?,Is this what the media is planning to do ???? People should decide and try to sue these media infiltrators.

There is one more setting in the  large picture where Major Gogoi did a huge favor to India and Indian’s…..Everybody in India saw the viral videos of our Paramilitary force personnel being slapped and their helmets thrown,while they were not reacting even though they had weapons,Just because they had strict orders not to shoot. Every self respecting patriotic Indian got enraged and felt so insulted because they have such a high respect for the forces ,The forces represent India’s identity,respect,strength and integrity,and when they were humiliated whole India could not take it,their hearts got ignited,People wanted revenge and their anguish could have  spilled on to the roads and large scale violence was waiting to happen,things could have gone into chaos,Suddenly Mr Gogoi seems to have done a miracle his act not only helped the situation in Kashmir but also whole of India,Only after that did Indians felt peace and things became normal. For this Major Gogoi needed a commendation and that he got through our General,Here it is worth mentioning our General because he also risked criticism from our anti nationalmedia but his commendation to Mr. Gogoi patted the Officer and made him feel secured and appreciated and by doing this he lifted the morale of the army and India , which was at an all time low.As far as the ongoing investigation on Mr. Gogoi is concerned, Our general heads the investigative committee and he is in touch with every second and every piece of the investigation,That is why before the investigation ended he knew first hand that the officer is not guilty of any violation, This made him give a commendation even though the investigation did not wrap up.

The author says repeatedly that a nations army should not be feared by its own people….Exactly that is what Our General and Major proved,That a nation’s people need not fear its army and the people in India will always be protected by the army BY risking their own lives,name and fame,But at the same time the Army will make sure that anti nationals and secessionists will always have to fear Indian army .

There is a famous political school of thought in the west which propagates the ideology that if you want to target and destroy an institution or country,You should select a single person or head of the institution and attack him ruthlessly, Until he is physically or politically or psychologically terminated,This according to them is the only way they can attack an institution or entity,thus causing irreparable damage to the institution or entity,Because they know that they cannot directly attack and succeed against an institution,They can only indirectly attack it by attacking an individual belonging to the entity. If you read through the lines,these days anti nationals and pseudo intellectuals are exactly doing this…They cannot directly attack India’s armed forces so they attack individuals belonging to Indian armed forces,They cannot attack Hinduism directly, so they pick individuals like Mr. Modi our beloved PM.
For patriotic Indians the picture of dhar tied to the jeep will not end like the napalm girl of Vietnam but it will be cherished by patriotic Indians like the Picture where arjuna is riding fearlessly accompanied by Krishna and charging at our country’s enemies…Jai Hind

 

  • 89
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
Article Categories:
Opinions · Politics

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *